Response at the local and individual level

We discussed how the larger government functions may cease to operate, or at a very basic level (perhaps just units of the US military). This will result in the following:

  • Food, specialized medical supplies, and gasoline/fuel quickly become unavailable. Most vehicle transportation is halted.
  • If enough critical workers leave their jobs, public utilities (water, sewer, and electric power) go down leaving people in the freezing cold and dark with no clean water.

Just losing the electric grid will cause this, since everything is driven by motors and pumps.  Is this too pessimistic? Maybe, but even if the effect is temporary it will be the worst thing to happen in our lifetimes.   At the very least we should be prepared to ride out this situation for a period of time, to stay alive.  Unfortunately, the majority of people do not this seriously and won’t make preparations. This leads to speculation as to what the response would be at the local and individual level.

Ideally, people would stay home, break out the supplies, and let things get back to some semblence of normality. Instead, they will likely be forced to leave in search of those fundamental items or end up as casualties. I suspect many will try to get to some relief center, if it exists.  As I mentioned in the Guns ‘N Ammo post, the lack of transpo and supply will limit how far people can travel foraging. Whether they start going door to door and/or turning violent is anyone’s guess. In any case, trouble would probably come from neighbors or those in walking distance. Here’s a few things to contemplate (and I sure don’t know the answer):

  • Would normal people start breaking into houses and killing the occupants for provisions?
  • Being armed and having some perceived authority, would the local gendarmes do this? Some of this went on in Katrina, so it’s not unprecedented.
  • Would people band together for mutual support, and would they then try to overpower other people or bands?
  • Would local government attempt to confiscate private property in the guise of the common good?

People are generally fairly adaptable and tend to lend support for others, even in desperate circumstances.  There’s not much data on how this might play out, other than in wartime (seige of Leningrad, 1944 Holland, Germany). In those cases, a central government still existed and the country was fully mobilized with Red Army or Nazi troops in place to put down any lawbreakers.  Bottom line is now, here in the US, we don’t know.  But we can guess at some likely scenarios, then prepare to them.  Here’s my shot at it:

Emergency begins. For a short time, people behave and can carry on in a somewhat normal fashion (as in a hurricane recovery).  As food runs out, stores are looted, first in urban areas then suburbs. Grocery, convenience, home improvement, gun stores cleaned out. As those supplies are depleted, what government is left tries to setup distribution centers/shelters. People go those, there are way too many for the limited supply and they are overrun. At this stage, they either return home to scrounge or wait for relief. Neither option is workable, and thirst and/or starvation sets in.   Time frame and casuality rate depend on the situation, could be weeks, months, or years and fractions a percent to near-100% respectively.  Recovery depends on the ability to sustain a population from whatever is left.

Thinking about this makes me realize there’s no way to know what you’d be faced with, you just have to plan for a potentially long term crisis.

Public and government responses to a real emergency, past and future

So we talked about what constitutes an major emergency, but what would happen afterwards? Frankly, no one really knows.  Let’s list some past events to see what we can glean from them.

Hurricane Katrina

In my  opinion, this was a demonstration of what would happen albeit on a small (city-wide) scale. Highlights:

  • Utter failure of local/city/state/federal responders.  Despite being limited to New Orleans and surrounding areas, it took forever for the Guard and Feds to get into the area and do basic rescue and supply operations.  Police disappeared, creating a lawless city. Keep in mind the rest of the country was not affected.
  • Non-existent/insufficient planning and backup supplies. The evacuation plan was comical, and was not implemented until far too late. Afterwards, there was no coherent plan to follow (just winging it).
  •  Reliance of the populace on “the authorities” to help them. Remember all the people in the dome with no food, water, sanitation, or medical attention?
  • Widespread looting. No cops, open season on stores.

This is the biggest disaster in memory, nothing else comes close in terms of disruption.  Because of the flooding, it was very difficult to get in and out of the city and showed how critical transportation and resupply from unaffected areas is to the crisis.

2009 H1N1 Swine Flu

This was a dress reheasal for contagion. Again, highlights:

  • Slow (excrutiatingly) response from WHO. The outbreak was in full swing in Mexico City before they showed up, and longer until they figured out what was going on.
  • Spread of the virus to the US and other places before any warnings were issued. It wasn’t until a school in NYC was infected and many students got sick did they issue a travel advisory.  By then it had popped up in multiple locations in the US.
  • Indifference to the situation by the public. I was shocked at how little people knew about H1N1 and that they might want to monitor events for their own safety.

SARS was a lot like this, it showed up in Canada before anyone really got the story.

I can’t think of any other really major events, but these have some potential to illustrate the potential response to a larger emergency. Takeaways:

  1. People will be slow to realize the true nature and scope of the emergency.
  2. The authorities may be incapacitated or spread so thin as to be ineffective.
  3. Few concrete and actionable plans, public or private, will exist to deal with said emergency.
  4. Aid and assistance will be delayed or minimal.